Papa Johns Pizza in Indiana

"“The pizza here is fantastic — crispy crust, plenty of toppings, and perfectly balanced flavors. Emily was the cook tonight and you can really taste the effort and skill she puts into every pie. One of the best pizza experiences I’ve had in a long time. Highly recommend! 5 stars"

"This is my favorite Papa John's in Indy! Their food is always fresh and delicious. They have a great friendly staff there. They are not in our delivery area but we always make the extra small trip to pick up our pizza from them. Keep up the good work! Best location ever!"

"Thank you for making my night! So blessed! Amazing! Blessings to whoever made my Pizza"

"Ive ordered here many times and Id figure its time to give yhem there well deserved 5 star rating. Its a good night when I smell the pizza from my room and I know I had Papa Johns. The delivery is fast and the workers are nice."

"The pizza was ready when it was picked up on time and hot when I got it home. We ordered the XL New Yorker and it was delicious. Baked to perfection. Will definitely be back."

"I came in to get some pizza and was fortunate enough to have Jeremiah help me with my order, he had great customer service and I could tell he actually loved what he does which is something you don't see anymore. My pizza looked so good you would think it was from a commercial it was perfectly made. I will be back"

"Dear Papa John’s Team, I hope this message finds you well. I’m a regular customer who greatly enjoys your pizza and dipping sauces. I wanted to provide some feedback regarding the sauce-to-pizza ratio, especially for larger orders and parties. To ensure a more consistent and enjoyable experience, I suggest the following ratios for dipping sauce: General Ratio: A 2:1 ratio of dipping sauce per 3 slices of pizza. This is based on the observation that one container of dipping sauce typically lasts for about 3 slices when used conservatively. Specific Suggestions: Small Pizza: Provide 3-4 containers of sauce for 6 slices. Medium & Large Pizza: Provide 5 containers of sauce for 8 slices. Extra Large (XL) Pizza: Provide 6-7 containers of sauce for 10 slices. This adjustment would help ensure that customers have enough sauce for their pizza, enhancing the overall dining experience, particularly for parties or shared meals. Thank you for considering my suggestion. I appreciate your attention to this matter and look forward to enjoying many more delicious pizzas from Papa John’s."

"Small mishap with my pizza mostly on my part. Ladies in the store were EXTREMELY sweet about it and offered to fix my issue with no problem. I always use this store and as long as they have people like the ladies I met I will continue to use it. Love it here."

"I have to preface this review with the fact that we always carry out. I can’t speak to the quality of the pizza that’s delivered but I can say we have used the specific Papa John’s for over 15 years and I can count on one hand the times we’ve got a pizza that was less than excellent. I guess I should also share that in that time we’ve ordered, with no exaggeration, we’ll over 150 pizzas! Keep up the great work staff at Papa John’s on Southport."

"I did have a significant wait on my order and it got lost after being put in the oven twice. However, the twi mamagers are really something special. The lady is an absolute boss at working with the dough and getting things done despite how busy it gets. And the man with red hair is super nice despite any attitude thrown at him. He stays professional and makes sure to keep everyone moving. His arm was in a sling when i went and he was still getting things done. When i did get our order, the cheesesticks were really good and the pizza was incredible. Their chicken poppers are really good too! If you like them super saucy i'd request extra sauce though."